DECISION OF THE SUPREME ARBITRATION COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

On behalf of the Russian Federation

of May 21, 2013 No. BAC-15415/12

The Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation as a part of the chief judge Vorontsova L. G., judges Kireykova G. G. and Shilokhvost O. Yu. in case of taking the minutes of judicial session by the assistant judge Zhavoronkina T. Yu. considered in proceeding in open court case on statements of "Circassian City Power Networks" open joint stock company and "Southern Interregional Energy Company" open joint stock company on recognition of paragraph one of Item 229 of Basic provisions of functioning of the retail markets of electrical energy approved by the order of the Government of the Russian Federation of 04.05.2012 of N 442, not to the corresponding regulatory legal acts having big legal force and invalid (taking into account refining of the statement).

Representatives took part in judicial session:

from society: Uskov K. G. by proxy of 09.11.2012 N 818;

from the company: Dudova D. K. - CEO of the company (minutes abstract of meeting of the Board of Directors of 24.02.2012 N 24); Dolgova O. V. by proxy of 29.03.2013 N 22; Indrikson Yu. E. by proxy of 04.10.2012 N 41; Kolontayevsky A. N. by proxy of 02.11.2012 N 50; Uskov K. G. by proxy of 17.10.2012 N 47;

from the Government of the Russian Federation on behalf of Federal Tariff Service based on orders of 29.11.2012 N VS-P9-7237 and of 22.12.2012 N VS-P9-7838: Peskovskaya O. G. by proxy of 10.01.2013 N 1/13; Stepanenko I. G. by proxy of 24.10.2012 N 12/13;

from the Government of the Russian Federation on behalf of the Ministry of Energy of the Russian Federation based on orders of 29.11.2012 N VS-P9-7237 and of 22.12.2012 N VS-P9-7838: Vikhansky A. E. by proxy of 08.05.2013 N AYa-4235/03, Savkin A. V. by proxy of 31.01.2012 N SSh-679/03.

The court established:

Disclaimer! This text was translated by AI translator and is not a valid juridical document. No warranty. No claim. More info