ORDER OF THE GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN

of April 17, 2009 No. 545

About approval of Rules of consideration, selection, monitoring and assessment of implementation of budget investment projects

List of amending documents

According to Item 8 of Article 153, Item 12 of Article 154, Item 10 of Article 157 of the Budget code of the Republic of Kazakhstan of December 4, 2008 the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan DECIDES:

1. Approve the enclosed Rules of consideration, selection, monitoring and assessment of implementation of budget investment projects.

2. Recognize to invalid:

1) the order of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan of March 18, 2005 No. 245 "About approval of Rules of consideration of budget investment projects (programs)" (SAPP of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2005, No. 12, the Art. 135);

2) the order of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan of March 18, 2005 No. 247 "About approval of Rules of forming of lists of priority budget investment projects (programs)" (SAPP of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2005, No. 12, the Art. 137).

3. This resolution becomes effective from the date of signing and is subject to official publication.

Approved by the Order of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan of April 17, 2009 No. 545

Rules of consideration, selection, monitoring and assessment of implementation of budget investment projects

1. General provisions

1. These rules of consideration, selection, monitoring and assessment of implementation of budget investment projects (further - Rules) are developed according to Item 8 of Article 153, Item 13 of Article 154, Item 10 of Article 157 of the Budget code of the Republic of Kazakhstan of December 4, 2008 and determine procedure:

1) developments, consideration and selection of investment offers on the budget investment projects including which are not requiring development of the feasibility statement;

2) considerations, selection of budget investment projects;

3) considerations, selection of the budget investment projects which are not requiring development of the feasibility statement;

4) considerations, selection of the budget investment projects assuming increase in estimated cost;

5) carrying out monitoring and assessment of implementation of budget investment projects.

2. In these rules the following concepts are used:

1) the administrator of budget programs - the state body responsible for planning, reasons, realization and achievement of results of budget programs;

2) the investment offer - the concept of the budget investment project reflecting it the purpose, ways of its achievement, including set of the relevant activities, developed by administrators of budget programs;

3) the budget investment project - set of the actions directed to creation (construction) new or reconstruction of the available objects, and also creation, implementation and development of the information systems realized at the expense of the budgetary funds during the certain period of time and having complete nature;

4) information leaf of the investment offer - the document containing the main information on the budget investment project, disclosing feasibility of its realization;

5) industry examination - assessment of the investment offer and/or feasibility statement on the budget investment project regarding compliance to priorities of development of industry, and also the choice of optimal variant of implementation of the budget investment project;

6) the feasibility statement on the budget investment project - documentation containing data on the main technical, technology and other solutions, and also results of studying of feasibility and efficiency of the budget investment project which is carried out on the basis of the economic analysis of benefits and costs with determination of the key technical and economic parameters;

7) adjustment of the feasibility statement - change established in the feasibility statement having the economic conclusion, technical and economic parameters of the project before approval of project (project and estimate) documentation of the technical solutions involving change and/or additional expenses, or after approval of the design estimates in case of need inclusion of the additional components which are not provided in the approved feasibility statement;

8) the specification on development or adjustment of the budget investment project - the document determining requirements to the feasibility statement on the budget investment project, qualification requirements to his potential developer, and also regulating terms and amount of works on development or adjustment of the feasibility statement on the budget investment project;

9) the economic conclusion on the investment offer - the conclusion of the central or local authorized body on state planning regarding economic feasibility of implementation of the investment project containing in the investment offer as the budget investment project, compliance of project objectives to the priorities of development of industry (sphere) of economy established by strategic and (or) program documents;

10) economic examination of the feasibility statement on the budget investment project - complex assessment of information provided in the feasibility statement, regarding determination of feasibility and efficiency of the project, carried out based on the conclusion of industry examination and others, the conclusions of examinations required according to the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan;

11) the economic conclusion according to the budget investment project - the conclusion of the central or local authorized body on state planning regarding economic feasibility of implementation of the budget investment project, its influence on national economy and the compliance to strategic and (or) program documents prepared based on the conclusion of economic examination of the feasibility statement on the budget investment project;

12) estimated cost - the construction cost of object (complex) determined according to estimate standard rates in case of development of the project documentation on construction;

13) monitoring of budget investment projects - set of actions for collection and information analysis about the course of creation (construction) new, reconstruction of the available objects from the moment of allocation of budgetary funds until commissioning;

14) assessment of implementation of budget investment projects - set of actions for determination of extent of goal achievement of the project and compliance of actually received results planned from the moment of commissioning;

15) the module of monitoring of budget investment projects of the electronic portal of authorized body on state planning - the information system intended for automation of accounting and monitoring of the planned and implementable budget investment projects (further - the PIP electronic portal);

16) the passport of the budget investment project - general information about the budget investment project;

17) Gant's chart - the chart used in the PIP electronic portal for illustration of graphical display of the sequence and duration of the project plan and the working schedule in time;

18) resource and infrastructure providing the budget investment project - the indicators characterizing the planned and reached level of need for resource and infrastructure security of the project;

19) financing sources on budget investments - means republican and/or local budgets, including borrowing in the foreign markets, directed to implementation of budget investment projects, joint financing of concessionary projects and participation of the state in the authorized capital of legal entities.

2. Procedure for development, consideration and selection of investment offers on the budget investment projects including which are not requiring development of the feasibility statement

1. Procedure for development, consideration and selection of investment offers on the budget investment projects requiring development of the feasibility statement

3. Process of development, consideration and selection of investment offers represents complex of the actions containing the following main stages:

1) submission of investment offers by administrators of budget programs to the central or local authorized body on state planning;

2) forming and approval of the list of budget investment projects, development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of feasibility statements (further - the feasibility study) on which are performed at the expense of means of the appropriate distributed budget program of the central or local authorized body on state planning.

4. Development of investment offers is performed by administrators of budget programs at stage of project development of strategic plans of state bodies.

5. Investment offers shall include the following documents:

1) information leaf of the investment offer;

2) information proving the cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study for the budget investment project;

3) the comparative table with indication of the technical solutions and/or additional expenses assumed to change according to the feasibility study for the budget investment project, and also the approved feasibility study for the budget investment project (in case of adjustment of the feasibility study for the budget investment project);

4) specification on development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study for the budget investment project;

5) industry examination of the investment offer;

6) the act of the representative the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan of body for internal control regarding target use of budgetary funds, and also about lack of violations (in case of adjustment of the feasibility study for the budget investment project) if according to the budget investment project financing is begun.

6. Information leaf of the investment offer contains information on compliance of project objectives to the priorities of development of industry (sphere) of economy established by strategic and (or) program documents, general information according to the budget investment project (further - the PIP), including its main indicators.

7. The information sheet of the investment offer is submitted in form according to appendix 1 to these rules.

8. For reasons for cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP are represented:

1) calculation reasons of cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP by components and terms of their development;

2) the list of necessary examinations with indication of the cost and the organization which is carrying out the corresponding expertize, except for economic examination.

9. Calculation reasons of cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP in the field of communication and informatization shall correspond to technique of the value assessment of information systems approved by the central authorized body in the field of communication and informatization.

10. Expected the PIP by administrators of budget programs is submitted to adjustment of the feasibility study the comparative table signed by the first head of the state body or person replacing it for review, or the deputy first head of state body with indication of the technical solutions and/or additional expenses assumed to change according to the feasibility study the PIP and the corresponding reasons on them, and also earlier approved feasibility study the PIP according to the procedure, established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

11. The specification on development or adjustment of the feasibility study the PIP is constituted based on requirements to development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP determined by authorized bodies by state planning in the field of communication and informatization and to cases of architecture, town planning and construction.

In the draft of the specification are also reflected:

1) qualification requirements to the potential feasibility study developer the PIP according to the legislation on public procurements;

2) scope and restrictions of obligations of developer according to the legislation on public procurements;

3) expected terms of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study PIP.

12. The conclusion of industry examination of the investment offer shall contain assessment:

1) problems of current status of industry which influences its further development;

2) the existing political, social and economic, legal and other conditions in which realization the PIP is supposed;

3) the indicators existing and predicted (for lifecycle the PIP of demand for products/services or social and economic need, taking into account the available competition in this region;

4) availability of engineering and transport infrastructure (long distance railways, highways, pipelines, electro-, heating systems, water supply systems, gas pipelines and other infrastructure);

5) the main socio-economic indexes and indicators characterizing location and area of influence the PIP, including assessment of availability of necessary resources (raw materials) for realization the PIP and their cost and assessment of conformity of the parcels of land planned to allocation to requirements the PIP;

6) the alternative options considered in case of the choice of way of solving the problem with reasons for the choice the PIP as optimum way of its decision;

7) possible options of situation in industry (sphere) of economy, in case of realization the PIP and without that;

8) the institutional scheme of management the PIP (the main participants, the scheme of their interaction, distribution of benefits and costs, asset holders, the scheme of management the PIP in the investment and post-investment periods);

9) expected risks on the PIP and actions for their minimization;

10) justification of calculations on the PIP.

13. If realization the PIP is offered at the expense of means of the republican budget, industry expertize of the investment offer is carried out by industry central state body.

14. If realization the PIP is offered at the expense of funds of the local budget or target transfers for development and the credits from the higher budget, industry expertize of the investment offer is carried out by the industry local executive body financed from the local budget.

15. On the PIP in the field of informatization the conclusion of industry examination of the investment offer of authorized body in the field of communication and informatization is required.

16. Industry examination of the investment offer is signed by the first head of state body of the corresponding industry or person replacing it and drawn up in the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan for official documents.

17. Administrators of budget programs create and represent to the central or local authorized body on state planning investment offers on development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP, with application of documents, the these rules specified in Item 5.

The documents specified in Item 5 of these rules are polistno initialed by the head of the structural unit of the administrator of budget programs responsible for development of the investment offer. For single system of electronic document management files are transferred in the electronic protected format interfering its editing.

18. In case of lack of documents which availability is necessary for carrying out the economic conclusion on the investment offer the central or local authorized body on state planning within 7 (seven) working days from the moment of receipt of document package returns them to administrators of budget programs.

19. The central or local authorized body on state planning considers investment proposals of administrators of budget programs on development (adjustment) of the feasibility study the PIP regarding economic feasibility, compliance of project objectives to the priorities of development of industry (sphere) of economy established by strategic and (or) program documents within 20 (twenty) working days and sends the economic conclusion on them to administrators of budget programs.

20. The economic conclusion on the investment offer on the PIP is submitted the central or local authorized body on state planning in form according to appendix 2 to these rules and contains the following main data:

1) general information on the project;

2) the expected result of accomplishment of the tasks determined by the strategic plan;

3) sources and amounts of financing;

4) development of the institutional scheme of project management (information on all project participants, both during realization, and during the post-investment period, their interaction);

5) availability of measurable (quantitative) indicators of direct result;

6) justification of calculations of cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study PIP;

7) conclusions.

21. Administrators of budget programs based on the positive economic conclusion on development or adjustment, and also on conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP represent to the central or local authorized body on state planning the letter on need of assignment according to the distributed budget program for development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP in the current year in which the positive economic decision, or in the following planned financial year is received.

22. The central authorized body on state planning creates the conclusions according to investment offers based on the positive economic conclusion on development or adjustment, and also on conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP and letters for financing of the administrator of budget programs and submits for consideration of the Republican budget commission.

23. The local authorized body on state planning following the results of consideration of investment offers creates according to them the conclusions and sends them for consideration of the budget commission based on the positive economic conclusion on development or adjustment, and also on conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP and letters on financing of the administrator of budget programs.

24. The conclusion according to investment offers submitted for consideration of the relevant budget commission shall contain the following main data:

1) name PIP(S);

2) the cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP(S) offered to financing by the administrator of budget programs;

3) the cost of development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP(S) offered to financing by authorized body on state planning;

4) compliance PIP(S) to strategic and (or) program documents of the Republic of Kazakhstan;

5) the expected result of accomplishment of tasks.

25. On the PIP, approved by the budget commissions, containing in investment offers, the central or local authorized body on state planning creates the list the PIP, development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study on which are performed at the expense of means of the appropriate distributed budget program of the central or local authorized body on state planning.

26. The list the PIP, development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP containing the name and the amount of financing on each project affirm the order of the central authorized body on state planning or regulatory legal act of local executive body which preparation is performed by the central or local authorized body on state planning.

27. Entering and consideration of additional offers into the investment offers which are earlier approved by the central or local authorized body on state planning before approval of the feasibility study the PIP, in case of change of the PIPS technical and economic parameters according to the offer of the relevant budget commission, in the procedure established by these rules is allowed.

In case of change of the PIPS technical and economic parameters before approval of the feasibility study the PIP, development, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP are performed within earlier provided means in the list the PIP, development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study on which are performed at the expense of means of the appropriate distributed budget program of the central or local authorized body on state planning.

2. Procedure for development, representation and selection of investment offers on the budget investment projects which are not requiring development of the feasibility statement

28. Development of investment project proposals, the feasibility study which is not requiring development, is performed by administrators of budget programs at stage of project development of strategic plans of state bodies.

29. The investment offer on everyone the PIP, to the feasibility study which is not requiring development, consists of the following documents:

1) information sheet PIP;

2) calculations and reasons for development (binding) and conducting examinations of the design estimates (further - the design and estimate documentation) on the projects which are not requiring development of the feasibility study for the project (in case of lack of the design and estimate documentation);

3) design assignment (in case of lack of the design and estimate documentation);

4) state examination on the design and estimate documentation of the project and the order on statement of the design and estimate documentation (in case of availability of the design and estimate documentation);

5) industry examination of the investment offer.

30. Information leaf of the investment offer contains information on compliance of project objectives to the priorities of development of industry (sphere) of economy established by strategic and (or) program documents, general information on the PIP including its key financial parameters.

31. The information sheet of the investment offer is submitted in form according to appendix 1 to these rules.

32. The proving calculations for development (binding) of the design and estimate documentation for the projects which are not requiring development of the feasibility study the PIP shall contain calculations with appendix of the corresponding proving documentation.

33. The conclusion of industry examination of investment project proposal, the feasibility study which is not requiring development, shall contain assessment:

1) problems of current status of industry which influences its further development;

2) the existing political, social and economic, legal and other conditions in which realization the PIP is supposed;

3) the indicators existing and predicted (for lifecycle the PIP) demand for products/services or social and economic need, taking into account the available competition in this region;

4) availability of engineering and transport infrastructure (long distance railways, highways, pipelines, electro-, heating systems, water supply systems, gas pipelines and other infrastructure);

5) the main socio-economic indexes and indicators characterizing location and area of influence the PIP, including assessment of availability of necessary resources (raw materials) for realization the PIP and their cost;

6) expected effect of realization the PIP on allied industries (spheres) of economy;

7) the alternative options considered in case of the choice of way of solving the problem with reasons for the choice the PIP as optimum way of its decision;

8) possible options of situation in industry (sphere) of economy, in case of realization the PIP and without that;

9) the institutional scheme of management the PIP (the main participants, the scheme of their interaction, distribution of benefits and costs of asset holders, the scheme of management the PIP in the investment and post-investment periods);

10) expected risks on the project and actions for their minimization;

11) justification of calculations on the PIP.

34. If realization the PIP is offered at the expense of means of the republican budget, industry expertize of the investment offer is carried out by industry central state body.

35. If realization the PIP is offered at the expense of means of the local budget or at the expense of target transfers on development and the credits from the higher budget, industry expertize of the investment offer is carried out by the industry local executive body financed from the local budget.

36. Industry examination of the investment offer is signed by the first head of state body of the corresponding industry or person replacing it and drawn up in the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan for official documents. 

37. Administrators of budget programs create and represent to the central or local authorized body on state planning the list of investment project proposals, the feasibility study which is not requiring development, with application of documents, the these rules specified in Item 29.

The documents specified in Item 29 of these rules are polistno initialed by the head of the structural unit of the administrator of budget programs responsible for development of the investment offer. For single system of electronic document management files are transferred in the electronic protected format interfering its editing.

Administrators of budget programs, in case of planning homogeneous (same) the PIP, the feasibility study which are not requiring development, creation of the single investment offer on the PIP is possible.

38. In case of lack of documents which availability is necessary for carrying out the economic conclusion on the investment offer the feasibility study which is not requiring development the central or local authorized body on state planning within 7 (seven) working days from the moment of receipt of document package returns them to administrators of budget programs.

39. The central or local authorized body on state planning considers investment offers on the PIP, the feasibility study for administrators of budget programs which is not requiring development, within 20 (twenty) working days and sends the economic conclusion on them to administrators of budget programs for form according to appendix 2 to these rules.

The economic conclusion on the single investment offer on homogeneous (same) the PIP, the feasibility study which are not requiring development, can be represented in complex on all projects or separately on each project, or by regions.

40. The conclusion according to investment offers submitted for consideration of the relevant budget commission shall contain the following main data:

1) name PIP(S);

2) calculations of cost for development (binding) of the design and estimate documentation for the projects which are not requiring development of the feasibility study the PIP, offered to financing by the administrator of budget programs (in case of lack of the design and estimate documentation);

3) calculations of cost for development (binding) of the design and estimate documentation for the projects which are not requiring development of the feasibility study the PIP, offered to financing by authorized body on state planning (in case of lack of the design and estimate documentation);

4) project cost according to state examination on the design and estimate documentation of the project and the order on statement of the design and estimate documentation (in case of availability of the design and estimate documentation);

5) compliance PIP(S) to strategic and program documents of the Republic of Kazakhstan;

6) the expected result of accomplishment of tasks.

3. Procedure for consideration and selection of budget investment projects

1. Procedure for consideration of budget investment projects

41. Consideration the PIP is performed by the central or local authorized body on state planning on the basis of the feasibility study developed according to the requirements to development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP determined by the central authorized body by state planning together with representatives by body for cases of architecture, town planning and construction and in the field of communication and informatization and the conclusions of economic examination of the feasibility study the PIP.

42. After development and conducting examinations of the feasibility study the PIP required according to the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, administrators of budget programs send their originals and copies to the central or local authorized body on state planning with submission of the electronic version of the feasibility study the PIP, including financial and economic model on the PIP which are polistno initialed by the head of the structural unit of the administrator of budget programs responsible for development of the feasibility study the PIP. For single system of electronic document management files are transferred in the electronic protected format interfering its editing.

43. The economic conclusion on the PIP is obligatory form of complex assessment of the economic analysis the PIP which is represented in form according to appendix 3 to these rules and is carried out within forty five working days after introduction of complete document package specified in Items 41, of 49-51 these rules where for the economic examination of the feasibility study the PIP performed by the corresponding legal entity thirty working days are taken away.

44. The central or local authorized body on state planning within 5 (five) working days from the moment of receipt of document package returns them to administrators of budget programs in cases:

1) lack of examinations which availability is necessary for conducting economic examination of the feasibility study the PIP;

2) absence in the feasibility study for Sections which availability is necessary according to the established requirements to development or adjustment, and also conducting necessary examinations of the feasibility study the PIP.

45. The central or local authorized body on state planning considers the PIP based on the conclusion of economic examination of the feasibility study the PIP and sends the economic conclusion on them to administrators of budget programs.

46. Economic examination of the feasibility study republican the PIP is performed by the legal entity determined by the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

47. Economic examination of the feasibility study local the PIP, and also the feasibility study the PIP, planned to financing at the expense of target transfers for development and the credits from the republican budget, can be performed by the legal entities determined by local executive bodies.

48. The central or local authorized body on state planning within 5 (five) working days sends the letter to the legal entity about need of conducting economic examination of the feasibility study the PIP with appendix of originals of the feasibility study and the corresponding examinations from the date of receipt of complete document package according to the feasibility study the PIP.

49. Economic expertize of the feasibility study the PIP is carried out based on the provided feasibility study the PIP and the corresponding positive conclusions of the examinations required depending on specifics of the project namely:

1) state examination of the legal entity authorized by the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan on implementation of state examination of projects;

2) conclusions of industry examination;

3) environmental assessment of authorized body in the field of environmental protection;

4) state scientific and technical examination;

5) examinations of authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological surveillance.

50. On the PIP, assuming construction activities, industry examination, the conclusion of the state, environmental and sanitary and epidemiologic examination on the feasibility study, and also the copy of the documents attached to task for development the feasibility study, including specifications, decisions of local executive bodies on withdrawal of the parcels of land on the projects assuming construction of new objects (with appendix in need of calculations of losses of owners of the parcels of land and land users, losses of agricultural and forestry and landscape production depending on type of the withdrawn grounds), and copies of the corresponding documents of title on real estate on the projects assuming reconstruction of the existing objects are required.

In case of availability of costs for commissioning of the facility the conclusions of industry authorized state body and state examination on expenses on commissioning of the facility (commissioning) according to departmental standard rates are required.

The design and estimate documentation the PIP, containing construction activities, is developed after approval of the feasibility study which passed the corresponding examinations in the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, except for the PIP, the feasibility study which are not requiring development.

50-1. In cost the PIP, assumed to financing from means of government external loans and joint financing of external loans from means of the republican budget, joins expenses on technical assistance, goods, training, consulting services in management, maintenance, institutional development, supervision of project construction. 

51. On the PIP in the field of informatization industry examination and the conclusion of authorized body in the field of communication and informatization are required.

The conclusion of authorized body in the field of communication and informatization contains assessment:

1) feasibility study compliance PIP to the specification on development of the feasibility study PIP;

2) problems of current status of industry. In this Section the problem in industry which is solved by realization created the PIP is determined;

3) the planned efficiency of realization the PIP on strategic and operational indicators of organization activity of the applicant according to the provided efficiency measure values;

4) technology and technical solutions. This Section contains assessment of conformity of technical characteristics of the equipment which is purchased within the project, to the purpose, tasks and capacity of the feasibility study the PIP, assessment of the offered options of realization of architecture of the project, and also assessment of the choice of the equipment on its compliance to the state and international standards, technological compatibility with already used equipment;

5) compliance the PIP to technical requirements and standards for integration of the decision with basic components of the electronic government. In this Section recommendations about integration the PIP with the state interdepartmental information systems are also described;

6) efficiency and feasibility of automation of processes of provision of the state services by means of the PIP. In this Section influence the PIP on the organization activity of the applicant directed to provision of the state services entering its competence and also to the state services provided by other state bodies and organizations is estimated;

7) the sequences, feasibility and effectiveness of realization created by the administrator of the PIPS budget programs within the existing information systems;

8) the created information systems and the PIPS components on compliance to requirements of information security;

9) alternative options, in particular the cost of ownership of the project, use of the ready decisions and outsourcing considered in case of the choice of way of solving the problem with reasons for the choice the PIP as optimum way of its decision includes also the analysis of all considered alternative options of decisions;

10) possible risks in case of realization the PIP and without that.

52. On the PIP, assuming innovative and/or space activities, the conclusion of the state scientific and technical examination is also required.

53. The conclusion of industry examination and the conclusion of the state scientific and technical examination the PIP provide assessment:

1) feasibility study compliance PIP to the specification on development of the feasibility study PIP;

2) problems of current status of industry which influence its further development;

3) the existing political, social and economic, legal and other conditions in which realization the PIP is supposed;

4) the indicators existing and predicted (for lifecycle the PIP) demand for products/services or social and economic need, taking into account the available competition in this region;

5) distributions of benefits and costs from realization the PIP;

6) the technology, technical solutions made in the feasibility study the PIP, including the schedule of realization the PIP;

7) price decisions, including ratio optimality assessment the price quality on all components of the investment and operating costs given in the feasibility study the PIP, comparison of planned prices on goods, works and services with the corresponding market prices;

8) the alternative options considered in case of the choice of way of solving the problem with reasons for the choice the PIP as optimum way of its decision;

9) possible options of situation in industry (sphere) of economy, in case of realization the PIP and without that;

10) justification of costs for commissioning of the facility according to the departmental standard rates approved by industry authorized state body.

54. Economic examination of the feasibility study the PIP planned to realization in the territory of other states, and also which is not providing construction activities is carried out on the basis of the feasibility study the PIP and the conclusions of examination of industry body to it.

Disclaimer! This text was translated by AI translator and is not a valid juridical document. No warranty. No claim. More info